The Opposite of Being a People Pleaser

*A full-time horse trainer who has written about horses (here) since 2010. My dogs think it’s their turn now.*

Every fall, there’s a competition between the trees and the north wind. Will the leaves slowly turn in the cooling sun or will the wind rip the leaves down before the tree is ready to let them go? It’s no contest. Freezing nights, cold days with no moisture at all. The ground is as parched by the north wind as my eyes and throat. It feels like the prairie is holding its breath, waiting for the next onslaught. Or is that me? It isn’t just that I don’t like it getting dark in the afternoon. It’s that I want to hide in a hole till the light comes back. Not that complaining changes a thing.

Then I saw him, up high in a tree. Too large for a hawk. He had a big head and no visible neck. Oh, the small tufts just barely visible. Great Horned Owls are shy birds, so it’s rare to see them in daylight with no camouflage. I didn’t move. Without a glance at me, he spread his wings and tipped off his branch, gliding away without a sound. Not a people pleaser.

 

I’ve been thinking about that trait after my last visit to watch the Bernese Mountain Dog owners have herding lessons at the instructor’s farm. I try to learn the phrases, like what it means to square the flank. After the demonstration, I had to ask if it was the flank of the dog or the sheep. I’m not a natural like Jolene.

I watched these dogs get distracted, get praised, get called off, and be made to sit when they wanted to chase. It was a boisterous wrestle. I pick up what I can and translate it to Vallhund, which will be a smaller, quieter language because little wolves don’t like to be bossed around.

At the end, the handler says, that’ll do, and these huge dogs bound to them, wiggling and squirming, their mouths open with tongues lolling out. One word of praise and they go boneless and besotted, melting into a squishy puddle. Then I try to remember the last time I had a dog like that. If I’m honest, I’m not wild about dogs like me too much, even if it would be convenient sometimes.

I mentioned it to the woman next to me. These dogs want to please their owners so much, I said, feeling a little sorry for myself. The woman, who is also a dog show judge, agreed. Her girl is lying at her feet, smiling. I mentioned, half under my breath, Jolene isn’t that way. The woman laughed. She says, no, Jolene is independent. The whole breed is very independent.

And just like that, I felt proud. Word choice is so important. The polarity of good or bad, right or wrong, makes winners and losers. Nothing is that absolute. Independent was just the word I was looking for. The opposite of a people pleaser.

Affirmative training, my horse approach, is based on never demonizing a behavior. Was the mistake the horse being disobedient or just confused? The word we choose flavors the entire experience, down to how we feel about our partner. And now I am contemplating the difference between independent and working to please me.  Raising my voice or getting loud with my stock stick will never be the answer for this multidimensional dog who is soft, yet wildly intelligent.

Jolene would like you to know that one of the advantages of not being a people pleaser is that she can keep her options open.  She is perfectly willing to follow any cue, unless a better idea comes up. I count the wins, ignore the rest. I need to be patient as she tames the ancestors that these sheep have resurrected within her. See how I did that? Word choice changes our understanding. It lets us see their side.

Last week a reader commented that she was fascinated by the differences between Mister and Jolene’s preferred activity levels, and that I managed to write about them without indicating a favorite. It’s a pragmatic choice. There’s no percentage in being judgmental. They are each my evil twin. Mister nods with approval. Then he closes his eyes because everybody knows the great philosophers meditate most of the day.

Meanwhile, the horses vacuum up every leaf that falls in their pen, crunching them down like Doritos. Leaving a hard-edged line between their work and mine. Make the list. Order the hay. Get another load of pea gravel.

I joined an online duck group looking for winter water solutions. One person shared photos of a duck wedding. Tux for him, off-the-shoulder confection for her. Another person asked for duck diaper patterns. Let’s observe a moment of silence for what would happen to me if I let the ducks come inside.

Google says the opposite of a people pleaser is authenticity and self-agency, rather than being rude, mean, or purely selfish as some think. A healthy person with boundaries. And we are vindicated by word choice!

This is my advice for those of you who dread the dark as I do. Buy some new socks. No kidding, they are primal attitude adjusters. Give yourself a shopping trip to the farm supply store. The best thing I found was a new leaf rake for mucking the sheep pen. Sure, I’ve had llamas for 25 years, but they make a designated spot for all the herd’s bodily functions, and it was a tidy pile, easy to pick up. Who knew sheep fertilize in a scatter pattern? Some winter days sanity hinges on the right tool for the job.

It occurs to me that there isn’t a people pleaser on the farm. Edgar Rice Burro is the most charming narcissist I know. Bhim, the mini, hates everyone, especially children. It gets worse. I notice I am not burdened with the need to please people either. I learned it from the best. Horses who had better things to do with their time than coddle me. Dogs who had minds of their own. Cats who were, well, cats.

It’s three in the morning, and I have to find a way to land this essay. The string that will tie all these thoughts together. Jolene’s positioned herself between me and my keyboard. She looks at me. She looks at the jar of chewies. She looks back at me. Two can play this game. I raise her bet and give her a squinty eye.

Mister is a few feet away; it’s too early for him to be up, but he’s watching the standoff. He knows my everybody-or-nobody treat policy. He depends on it because he has even less desire to please me than Jolene. He also knows there is a chewie time, and that time is not now.

The high drama of negotiation continues. A steely-eyed war of wills. For years and years, if we’re lucky.

…

Do you ever think you might have a book in you? Are you curious about writing? In January, I’m teaching a month-long writing workshop entitled How to Write a Memoir If You’re a Nobody. Obviously, everyone is welcome. Sign up here.

And a reminder: Books are a great holiday gift. They’re the same price they were the day they were published, inflation be damned. Available at all online booksellers, Amazon, Barnes and Noble, and signed copies from me.

… 

#noai #humanart

An audio version of this essay is available to subscribers who receive two podcasts a week on Substack.

Find Anna Blake and The Gray Mare Podcast on Substack or BlueSky social media. Contact me directly at annablake.com. #deletefacebook

My books include three creative nonfiction books, two memoirs, and two poetry books. Available at all online booksellers, Amazon, Barnes and Noble, and signed copies from me. Please consider leaving a rating or review.

Join us at The Barn School (opens in new tab), our social and equine educational site, with member sharing and our infamous Happy Hour. Everyone’s welcome. For specific horse training advice, search 1500 essays archived on my website. Want more? Become a sustaining member, a Barnie. (opens in new tab). Subscribe to our online group and join the best bunch of like-minded horse people anywhere.

Ride for a new brand. Find our Relaxed & Forward and Undomesticated Women swag at Zazzle.

Women Aging Cantankerously

This blog is free, and it always will be. Free to read, but also free of ads because I turn away sponsorships and pay to keep ads off my site. I like to read a clean page and think you do too. If you appreciate the work I do, or if your horse does, consider making a donation.

Anna Blake

10 thoughts on “The Opposite of Being a People Pleaser”

  1. Your philosophical writing really speaks to me. I have slowly changed my outlook and approach to training my horse from reading your posts. I have always heard my animals talk to me and love reading about yours and their conversations.

    Reply
    • Thank you, Shannon. Things around here seemed to improve the more I accept who the animals are. The rest is just conversation…

      Reply
  2. That was a lovely entry. I read them every week but this one was just right for today. I appreciate you in my email every Thursday. Thank you for being here.

    Reply
  3. I love semantics and this is a good one for me. It reminds me of a conversation with my father about my brother and his McEnroe level of upset in some athletic competition. Not the wind and tree kind. I said that maybe he was too competitive. My father, who wasn’t usually a word person, or a people pleaser. He had a natural trait of liking people, and so people liked him a lot. And he was a competitor at heart. He was not much for thinking of pleasing people, ever, but he easily did. He said, regarding my brother, no, not too competitive, but my brother staked too much in winning for other peoples’ opinions. (Probably mostly my father’s opinion.) And yes, as a kid, my brother always wanted to be liked. So a people pleaser. As a kid, I didn’t even have the thought in my mind that a person could be that, and later, I learned I actually secretly was one. On that, I would say I am jealous of your Great Horned Owl sighting, but would never take it away from you. As I age, I’m learning the art of vicarious pleasure, imagining the feeling. So, thank you for sighting the owl, she the quiet observer of all natural competitions, especially between tree and wind. Great photo catch! And apologies for going on and on!

    Reply
    • Oh Minna, what a perceptive comment your father made. So much more nuance than right or wrong. So thoughtful. And if it weren’t for the quick photo, I might not have believed it.

      Reply
  4. “Melting into a squishy puddle “ -perfect !
    That is a brilliantly designed rake, ticks of approval-the right tool does make a huge difference.
    I was hoping the ducks would get a mention then nearly choked on my cup of tea when they did😂
    A friend sent a link for me to watch a cat walking on its hind legs. It was genuine. The cat was at its third home and wanted connection with the new owners. One day it moved a couple of steps on hind legs while frisking about. That got positive attention from the owners! So it practiced some more. That’s what I thought affirmative training of cats looks like😊

    Reply

Leave a Comment